Up In The Air (Reviewed by Sebastian Ng)
(Nominated at the 2010 Oscars for Best Picture, Best Directing, Best Actor (George Clooney), Best Supporting Actresses (Vera Farmiga & Anna Kendrick), and Best Adapted Screenplay.)
Oscar season is upon us! This is traditionally a time when I get as worked up as most men and boys get during football season. However, I'm a bit more muted this year; the movie I'm rooting for isn't gonna get any proper Oscar love (hint: it involves "prawns").
Meanwhile, every year, there are always a couple of movies that leave me flabbergasted by how many Oscar nominations they receive. If I merely resented them at the point of watching them, my resentment turns into irascible petulance after they suddenly sprout seemingly uncountable nominations and awards.
This year, one of those movies is Up In The Air.
Don't get me wrong, I cannot deny that it is a well-executed film. A television film. To use that slightly derisive Americanism: "oh, that belongs on Hallmark channel".
Credit where it is due: the screenplay by Jason Reitman and Sheldon Turner is excellent, and does deserve its many Adapted Screenplay nominations. (Though I think An Education is the superior screenplay and should be the ultimate winner in all cases.) Mostly because the dialogue is constantly amusing - thanks to the confidently blasé main character, Ryan Bingham and the frequently insightful observations about people in airports and on flights.
What I don't get are the accolades bestowed on the actors. Sure, George Clooney and Anna Kendrick and Vera Farmiga serve their roles well - good dialogue delivery, and being on the mark at conveying their characters' attitudes. But it feels as if Clooney was nominated simply for his charm (again); and Kendrick because of that little crying scene she did - nicely played and a good twist, but a bit too light.
The editing was fine; it was exhilarating to see the fast-cuts used in the montages demonstrating Bingham's airport routines. But, otherwise, by the time I reached the third act of the movie, I wondered why I was still watching. The nicely cynical protagonist has, predictably, opened up to a side of him that craves relationships and connections, just so that the movie can affirm the normalcy of the dull masses. Oh, whoopee. In fact, what made the character interesting before was that he was different and persuasively so.
Am I then saying: "Don't watch the film?" Well no, I can't say that. You should watch it, if nothing else because it is one of very few Oscar Best Picture nominees that made it to our shores this year. And then you can decide for yourself whether you agree with this review, or not.
By the way, I'd love to hear your opinions in the comments section below. Hint.
Director Jason Reitman Cast George Clooney, Anna Kendrick, Vera Farmiga, Jason Bateman Runtime 111 mins Opens 4 March
~
Sebastian Ng studied filmmaking at the Los Angeles Film School in Hollywood, majoring in Directing and Sound Design. He currently works as a digital production coordinator for Rhythm & Hues Studios (Malaysia), and continues to fuel his passion for film by writing reviews and other ramblings for his blog, Cinematic Concerns.
< Previous: Catholic Church wants apology from Al-Islam; Wyclef & Fatboy Slim in KL; granny DJ rocks the dancefloor
MORE ARTICLES
2 COMMENTS
I think the film is deftly executed for the precise reason that the material was so tough to adapt to begin with. Take a read of the book, it's all in this one guys head a lot of the time. That alone makes it laudable on so many levels.
The other reason I think it makes such an impact is simply because it is very human. Bingham's feelings are very close to home to basic truths of the human experience.
And it's simple as well.
I think it's highly unfair to call it a "television movie". Far from it. In fact, Reitman is probably the only filmmaker who is making films that harken to the heyday of American cinema in the 70's (think classics like Five Easy Pieces, Badlands etc) albeit with a very 21st century attitude.
Alongside The Hurt Locker & Let The Right One In, it really is one of the finer, classier movies of 2009.
Half of the article is about your dislikes and preferences, when in actual fact is should be about properly reviewing the movie for us, dear readers. A very self-indulgent piece (the review, not the movie).
LEAVE A COMMENT
Anyone can comment anonymously, but if you sign in, you can track replies to your comments or send other users private messages. Your email address will not be public, but is required.





