| Forgot your password?
REGISTER!
Klue
Around Town
KLue Recommends
23-aug-tile

This week features an exciting mix of events, from a live music performance by students of the International College of Music to a delicious Ramdhan meal, just like how grandma prepares!

Click to view our full Checklist this week
  Events
  Calendar
September
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293012
  Latest
Magazine

ISSUE #142

142_cover

Tolled highways, Nik Aziz T-shirts, storm drains, and more: for Merdeka month, KLue presents 53 objects that define our Klang Valley experience in these last 53 years of independence! 

Read More
SUBSCRIBE
Film
3idiots_big_std

3 Idiots (Reviewed by Sebastian Ng) Review

Tuesday, 05/01/10 - 13:13PM Filed in Film by zedeck | Views: 3418 | Comments: 3

Just like audiences for local Malay movies are, like, 98% Malay, the audiences for Bollywood films in cinemas -- everywhere, not just Malaysia -- is usually devoid of non-Indian people. Anyway, that's my justification for not going for Bollywood films at the cinema very often. So why did I watch this, then?

Because the Hollywood trade mag Variety actually bothered to review it and gave it a fairly glowing review. Which I've never seen happen before.

And boy, was I entertained! I haven't been so entertained in such a long time. In fact, because of the surprise at how much I enjoyed this, I kinda dug this even more than Avatar!

Like most Bollywood films, the synopsis can be horribly long-winded (half of the film is taken up by flashbacks, as is typical), but it's basically about three friends and their many trials and tribulations (and other funny incidents) in engineering college. One of the friends, Rancho, stands out by being the perfect character: has his head about him, smarter than everyone without being arrogant. Later, Rancho disappears for ten years -- and thus ensues a road-trip adventure with the objective of locating him that is full of twists and turns.

The film's themes come across very strongly. It is about education: how and why we study; rote memorisation vs genuine understanding; failure-induced suicides; parents' projected hopes and dreams; and the big one --competitiveness. Now, this is relevant to Indian society, of course -- but extremely relevant to Malaysian students and their parents as well.

I guess Jack Neo's I Not Stupid immediately comes to mind, but 3 Idiots is such a well-written movie that none of the preachiness of that Singaporean film ever surfaces here. Also, the plot contrivances are far harder to detect under all the well-linked and highly entertaining scenes - I know, because it took me more than a day to unravel the contrivances, and I had to try. I've spoken of the importance of setups and payoffs in writing films; 3 Idiots is a great example of how to do it well. (3 Idiots was adapted from Chetan Bhagat's Five Point Someone, which the movie no longer resembles; scripting reportedly took years.)

Aamir Khan, whom I was surprised to find out is already in his 40s, offers up a youthful and charismatic portrayal of Rancho, shuffling between slapstick comedy and the occasional heartfelt melodrama effortlessly. Crucially, no one ever drops the ball among the fairly large ensemble cast.

Talking about competitiveness, the movie seemed to be aiming to do everything in the best way possible. You have here the best first-day-at-school speech by the principal, the funniest school speech that has been reworked for a prank ever (you learn the meaning of the word "balatkar"), one of the most head-scratchingly "WTF" intermission cliffhangers ever (which they manage to resolve in a plausible manner), and the best emergency baby delivery sequence ever (oh yeah, that's up there too). 

Je vous en prie, go see this smart and wildly entertaining film before its limited run at Malaysian cinemas is over.

~

How Good The Film Is: 8.5/10

How Much I Liked It: 9/10

Director Rajkumar Hirani Cast Aamir Khan, Kareena Kapoor, R. Madhavan, Sharman Joshi Runtime 170 mins Opens 25 Dec

~

 

Sebastian Ng studied filmmaking at the Los Angeles Film School in Hollywood, majoring in Directing and Sound Design but spent most of his time watching movies, and attending film festivals and meet-the-filmmaker sessions. Having returned to Malaysia in 2008, he currently works as a digital production coordinator for Rhythm & Hues Studios (Malaysia). He continues to fuel his passion for film by writing reviews and other ramblings for his blog,Cinematic Concerns.

Check out Sebastian's coverage of the PIFF2009 in KLue's December issue!

 


Email KLue
Share this article with your friends via E-mail, Facebook, Myspace, Digg and more.

3 COMMENTS

Nice to see a non-indian enjoy this movie so much... especially since I thought (till now) that most of the humor was india-specific... guess a gud film crosses all barriers

Default_user
Posted by Ashish Biswas on 06 January

If you have liked this movie, you should watch "Taare Zameen Par" Produced, directed and starring Aamir Khan. While '3 Idiots' deals with higher education, 'Taare zameen Par' deals with primary education and children with learning difficulties.
It would be futile for me to describe the movie, so just grab a DVD of this 2007 release.

Default_user
Posted by Sajeet on 06 January

Incidently, 3 idiots is the highest earning bollywood film ever. It created that record in mere 10 days of its release.

Default_user
Posted by Sajeet on 06 January

LEAVE A COMMENT

Anyone can comment anonymously, but if you sign in, you can track replies to your comments or send other users private messages. Your email address will not be public, but is required.

  1. Comment
  2. User Login


    Anonymous Comment




  3. Not Registered?

    Create an Account with KLue! Register Now!

  Klassifieds
Directory
  Gallery
Twitter
Comments
"Dear Blaze, whattt are you complaining about? K..." by cocobanana in Word Up: Flaggerific
"it seems the traffic was massively jammed..is t..." by pity in KLue's Buka Puasa Guide 2010: SS18 Subang Jaya
"All the best Nadiah! Will always support you an..." by cliff in Interview: Nadiah Hamzah needs help to make a film about M'sians in NY!
"I'm proud to be a backer. Go Nadiah! And thanks..." by cthulhu in Interview: Nadiah Hamzah needs help to make a film about M'sians in NY!
"I think David is so teribbly sick. That's a mas..." by Vincent in Blood, sweat & tears: David Gurnani is Asia's first Biggest Loser!
"Sorry, I should correct myself... "However..." by ilann in Word Up: Flaggerific
"Sabah & Sarawak formed Malaysia. Without th..." by ilann in Word Up: Flaggerific
"why r u so jealous with them.. they r talented ..." by suri cruz in Marion Caunter & Dominic Lau are Asia's Ryan Seacrest & Giuliana Rancic
"16 September is the day when Sabah and Sarawak ..." by blaze in Word Up: Flaggerific
Tag Cloud
Poll
What do you think is the best way to reduce road accidents this festive season?
  Provide discount for toll prices at night to ease traffic congestion during the day
  Ban heavy vehicles from using the highways during peak hours
  Set up more roadblocks and ensure that speedtrap units are clearly visible and obvious
  Safety campaigns at every highway R&R
  Free coffee at petrol stations along the highway and rest areas